• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to New York Pizza Company, East Ridge

Located in Chattanooga, Tennessee, New York Pizza Company, East Ridge brings a slice of authentic New York to the South. Founded by a passionate Long Island native, the pizzeria boasts fresh, high-quality ingredients and classic recipes that create a flavorful experience, from its light, crispy dough to the hand-shredded cheese. Customer favorites include the perfectly balanced grandma slice and the stuffed calzones, each paired with a rich house-made marinara. Diners rave about the welcoming atmosphere and attentive staff, making it a must-visit for pizza lovers seeking genuine New York-style fare. Your taste buds will thank you for stopping by!

New York Pizza Company, East Ridge: Reviews & Ratings

John Johnson
John Johnson

New York style pizza has a different set of fresh ingredients and recipe and cooking style just everything about it is different and this place is authentic New York Pizza and there's no better pizza in the city of Chattanooga than New York Pizza Company!

Ross Blank
Ross Blank

Tasty pizza, NY style. Friendly and professional staff. Nice n clean ambiance, but looks like they might still be putting some things away from a move? Regardless, great pizza. Kiddos thought it was pretty darn good, too.

Ruben Castro
Ruben Castro

Finally able to stop in to try their pizza, live in Cleveland. I’m a bit of a pizza snob, grew up in Brooklyn, and can’t find true NY style locally. As soon as my wife and I entered the place, the smells bought back the memories of home. Met the owner, Nannette and had a great time talking with her. Ordered a pizza to go and while waiting, had to try a slice of the Sicilian pizza, it was “like butta”, crisp on the bottom and soft on the inside. Got home and had the regular pizza, with sausage, and it was amazing. will be back!

Haley B
Haley B

This place is INCREDIBLE. The owner is from Long Island. It is true New York pizza. Not simply ‘New York style’. This place is legit. The dough is light and has a crunch when reheated. The sauce is perfect and flavorful and doesn’t give any indigestion. The cheese is hand shredded. This is not your average Pizza Hut. This is what pizza should taste like. If you were in New York, this would be one you would go out of your way for. If you don’t know what a grandma ‘slice’ of pizza is- I describe it as a thinner Sicilian. They dollop the sauce on top and then a bit of garlic oil and fresh basil. They also make a Sicilian, which I normally don’t care for because it gets too bready and doughy- but their crust is light with a crunch on the bottom. Really, do yourself a favor and check this place out. My husband and I have been going here for two years and it is consistent and FABULOUS. stop thinking about the traffic and go try it. You haven’t lived yet. You can thank me later.

Rian Bergen
Rian Bergen

Probably the best restaurant pizza I’ve had in a very long time. Well worth the trip for me. The pizza itself tasted awesome!! Very well flavored. The dough was light and crispy. The slices were well structured and not greasy. The people were also very friendly. They have plenty of options for very fair prices. Highly recommend! The cheese pizza and the bread sticks were awesome. Definitely give it a try if you are in the area. *All the meat options are chicken, turkey, and beef. This definitely is a unique and cool thing. They also have dairy free options, and plenty of salads.

Bradley Chambers
Bradley Chambers

I’ve tried every pizza place within a 30 mile radius of Chattanooga and this is by far the best pizza in the area. My family did a taste test comparing multiple other pizza, places in Chattanooga and this place won by landslide. The flavor is great. The calzones are also delicious. If you love pizza, do yourself a favor and get an order placed ASAP.

Dawn LaPrad
Dawn LaPrad

I was born and raised in NYC. This pizza is the real thing. Check it out!

Connie Weiss
Connie Weiss

We were devastated with NYPD (closer to our home) closed but relocated & reopened with a changed recipe. Their pizza went downhill & we had no replacement in our area. Them we heard this couple from our church opened their own place. It’s very far away from us so it took us awhile to get there & now we’ve been there twice in a little over a month! We’ve got our excellent thin crunchy NY crust and perfect toppings again! If you have not been here, you have to try it. We’re hooked!

Location

Welcome to New York Pizza Company, East Ridge! Nestled in the bustling heart of Chattanooga at 5084 South Terrace #136, this pizzeria brings a slice of the Big Apple right to your neighborhood. With a phone number to reach them at +1 423-654-3946, you’ll want to keep this gem on speed dial!

New York Pizza Company has earned a stellar reputation among locals and visitors alike, with notable praise coming from residents like John Johnson, who states, “this place is authentic New York Pizza.” If you're a pizza aficionado, you'd agree that pizza isn't just food: it's an experience, and this restaurant pulls you right into the vibrant culture of NYC.

Outstanding Menu Offerings

The menu presents an impressive selection of both 12-inch and 18-inch pizzas. Signature pies include:

  • Smoked BBQ Brisket Pizza - House smoked brisket, tangy BBQ sauce, onion, tomatoes, and fresh basil.
  • Meat Lovers Pizza - For the carnivore at heart, stacked with pepperoni, sausage, ground beef, bacon, and ham.
  • White Pizza - A fan favorite, featuring garlic, olive oil, ricotta cheese, and mozzarella, offering a creamy delight.
  • Veggie Pizza - A colorful mix of fresh bell peppers, onions, mushrooms, and more, perfect for the veggie enthusiasts.

Many customers rave about the hot and sassy pizza, an enticing blend of pepperoni and ricotta topped with jalapeños and Mike’s Hot Honey, showcasing a delightful harmony of flavors.

Ambiance and Service

With a friendly, professional staff and a clean ambiance, patrons like Ross Blank appreciate the atmosphere. Although they may still be unpacking from a move, the positive vibes and fantastic pizzas more than make up for any minor transition hiccups.

A True Taste of New York

What truly sets New York Pizza Company apart is its commitment to authenticity. In the words of Haley B, “this is not your average Pizza Hut. This is what pizza should taste like.” The dough is made to perfection, offering a light and crunchy texture that pairs exquisitely with their flavorful sauce.

As Ruben Castro noted, stepping inside the pizzeria is akin to a nostalgic journey back to Brooklyn. It’s the smells, the laughs, and the heartfelt conversations with staff and the owner, Nannette, that create an environment where you feel right at home.

Why You Should Visit

If you find yourself in the Chattanooga area, do yourself a favor and check out New York Pizza Company, East Ridge. Whether you’re grabbing a slice after a long day or hosting a pizza party at home with their takeout options, the experience is sure to delight. You may even want to take your time – like Rian Bergen says, “probably the best restaurant pizza I’ve had in a very long time.”

Don't miss out on the chance to savor authentic New York-style pizza. Your taste buds will thank you!